More Thoughts on Possibly Saying Goodbye to AS

15 Oct

The new Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-Fifth Edition (DSM-V) will eliminate the diagnostic category of Asperger’s Syndrome, 16 years after its inception in the DSM-IV. “Asperger” symptoms will be combined with those of another mild form of autism to create a new category to be named.

I agree with judiciously reviewing the characteristics across the autism spectrum. Medical professionals have long questioned the efficacy of Pervasive Developmental Disorder-Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS); the DSM-IV-Text Revision states that PDD-NOS can also be referred to as “atypical autism.” In simple terms, the essential features of PDD-NOS are severe and pervasive impairment in the development of reciprocal social interaction or verbal and nonverbal communication skills or stereotyped behaviors, interests, and activities. The criteria for Autistic Disorder are not met because of late age onset; atypical and/or sub- threshold symptomology are present. In my practice, parents express confusion about this diagnostic category, what it means in relation to autism and AS, and how to operationalize it. Some replace PDD-NOS with AS, as they believe that school districts understand and provide services more readily for AS.

A review of Asperger’s Syndrome criteria might also be warranted. Individuals with AS are supposed to have “no clinically significant delay” in the development of age-appropriate self-help skills. Does your child with AS ask for help when needed, take a shower daily, brush his/her teeth without several reminders, and pick clothing appropriate to the weather? I find that skills of this nature are very challenging for all kids on the autism spectrum, especially those with AS who are expected to function at levels commensurate to their cognitive abilities. With regard to the former, more and more documentation indicates that individuals with AS need not be savants or geniuses. They may excel in one academic area with significant struggles in others.

Anyone who has an ASD or knows someone with an ASD can attest to the symptoms that could (or perhaps should) be added to the diagnostic criteria across the spectrum: handwriting challenges, sensory hyper- and hyposensitivity, personal hygiene struggles, and early menstruation in females to name a few. Feel free to respond to this article with your thoughts on what should be added, removed, or at least considered by the DSM-V.

The driving force for educational and therapeutic individualization has always been the understanding that no two individuals with ASD are alike; apparently, this has become a liability. It seems to me that in removing the Asperger’s Disorder diagnosis in favor of another category, we are eradicating the possibility of further diagnostic clarify in the DSM-V. Not to mention that we are making an invisible disability even more obscured.

Starting February 10, the public is invited to comment on the Asperger’s working group’s report on the DSM website.


2 responses to “More Thoughts on Possibly Saying Goodbye to AS

  1. Corina Becker

    October 15, 2010 at 4:46 PM

    “Does your child with AS ask for help when needed, take a shower daily, brush his/her teeth without several reminders, and pick clothing appropriate to the weather?”

    Hey, I resemble that!! Even now, as an adult!!!

  2. Tam

    October 15, 2010 at 10:43 PM

    I’m not sure on this one, isn’t easier to just say “my kid has autism” or “I have autism” and worry about where on the spectrum individually? I don’t get why we have to have a specific category for each “presentation” if we’re going to agree that no two individuals are alike anyway.

    It seems to me if the only label is “autism spectrum disorder” or some such, then the insurance companies can’t have a list of helps they’ve approved for PDD-NOS vs their approved list for Asperger’s vs their approved list for autism… they’ll have to have one list, and the people working with your child will be the ones to deem which services he/she needs.

    Maybe I’m wrong or I don’t understand the changes/issues fully. I’ll admit to not having looked into this all that far. But it makes so much sense to me to lump it all in one category, especially since the differences simply are not cut and dry.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: